| Award | Recipient | |
Newcombe - Todd Cup (Lost forever...) Presented to the BFHL Champion |  | 09-10 Storm 10-11 Supastas (nka Honeybadgers) 11-12 Nokians 12-13 Storm* 13-14 Storm 14-15 Storm 15-16 Honeybadgers 16-17 Alpacas 17-18 Gunners 18-19 Nokian 19-20 Honeybadgers 20-21 Honeybadgers 21-22 Poutiners 22-23 Samurai 23-24 Honeybadgers 24-25 Kenobi 25-26 TBD * Only because the league conspired against Bombers and veto'd all his trade deadline deals. |
| Presidents Trophy (Team w/ Most Pts) |  | 09-10 Aviators 10-11 Tony the Tigers (nka Roaches) 11-12 Nokians (114 points) 12-13 Bullies (133 points) 13-14 Bullies (128 points) 14-15 Bombers (133 points) 15-16 Honeybadgers (135 points) 16-17 Bullies (114 points) 17-18 Thrashers (147 points) 18-19 Bullies (145 points) 19-20 Honeybadgers (143 points) 20-21 Roaches (103 points) 21-22 Thrashers (135 points) 22-23 Honeybadgers (126 points) 23-24 Nokians (143 points) 24-25 Nokians (138 points) 25-26 Bombers (157 points) |
| Conn Smythe (Playoff MVP) |  | 09-10 Jamie Langenbrunner (STO) 10-11 Roberto Luongo (AVI) 11-12 Henrik Lundqvist (NOK) 12-13 Cory Schneider (STO) 13-14 James Neal (STO) 14-15 James Neal (STO) 15-16 Roberto Luongo (HBR) 16-17 Alex Ovechkin (ALP) 17-18 Rickard Rakell (GUN) 18-19 Antti Raanta (NOK) 19-20 Alex Ovechkin (HBR) 20-21 Mika Zibanejad (HBR) The league stopped tracking this arbitrary award after the 20-21 season. |
| Hart Trophy (MVP) |  | 09-10 Brian Rafalski (AVI) 10-11 Henrik Sedin (TIG, nka RCH) 11-12 Andy Mcdonald (BRS, nka KEN) 12-13 Evgeni Malkin (BSB) 13-14 Jonathan Toews (AVI) 14-15 Sidney Crosby (NES) 15-16 Jamie Benn (HBR) 16-17 Alex Ovechkin (ALP) 17-18 Jeff Carter (GUN) 18-19 Tyler Seguin (PRT) 19-20 Steven Stamkos (KNB) 20-21 Mika Zibanejad (HBR) The league stopped tracking this arbitrary award after the 20-21 season. |
| Vezina (Best Goalie) |  | 09-10 Roberto Luongo (AVI) 10-11 Chris Mason (CDR) 11-12 Henrik Lundqvist (NOK) 12-13 Jonathan Quick (BRS, nka KEN) 13-14 Henrik Lundqvist (TIG, nka RCH) 14-15 Marc-Andre Fleury (STO) 15-16 Roberto Luongo (HBR) 16-17 Pekka Rinne (BSB) 17-18 Sergei Bobrovski (THR) 18-19 Pekka Rinne (BSB) 19-20 Ben Bishop (HBR) 20-21 Connor Hellebyuck (BOM) 21-22 Andrei Vasilevskiy (GUN) 22-23 Igor Shesterkin (SAM) 23-24 Linus Ulmark (NOK) 24-25 Sergei Bobrovsky (HBR) 25-26 Connor Hellebyuck (BOM) |
| Norris (Best Defenseman) |  | 09-10 Mike Green (STO) 10-11 Duncan Keith (NOK) 11-12 Keith Yandle (WOR) 12-13 Shea Weber (WOR) 13-14 Erik Karlsson (STO) 14-15 Erik Karlsson (STO) 15-16 Erik Karlsson (STO) 16-17 Erik Karlsson (KNB) 17-18 Erik Karlsson (KNB) 18-19 Erik Karlsson (KNB) 19-20 Kris Letang (PRT) 20-21 Dougie Hamilton (HBR) 21-22 Drew Doughty (RCH) 22-23 Roman Josi (POU) 23-24 Cale Makar (PHI) 24-25 Roman Josi (POU) 25-26 Cale Makar (PHI) |
| Calder (Top Rookie) |  | 09-10 Kris Versteeg (AVI) 10-11 Jamie Benn (SUP, nka HBR) 11-12 Logan Couture (STO) 12-13 Ryan Nugent-Hopkins (COY, nka GNG) 13-14 Brendan Gallagher (TIG, nka RCH) 14-15 Nathan MacKinnon (SHE) 15-16 Filip Forsberg (SUV) 16-17 Jack Eichel (GUN) 17-18 Auston Matthews (SHE) 18-19 Nico Hischier (PHI) 19-20 Elias Pettersson (BOM) 20-21 Max Comtois (SAM) 21-22 Kirill Kaprizov (LEO) 22-23 Trevor Zegras (BOM) 23-24 Andrei Kuzmenko (WOR) 24-25 Connor Bedard (JMX) 25-26 Macklin Celebrini (YET) |
Selke (Solid players who can supplement scoring while being defensively sound, but not necessarily best defensive forward until 17-18 when it was awarded to good defensive forwards) |  | 09-10 Johan Franzen (MDM, nka ALP) +25 10-11 Colby Armstrong (GIA, nka KEN) +35 11-12 Antoine Vermette (CDR) 12-13 Patrice Bergeron (THR) 13-14 Patrice Bergeron (THR) 14-15 Ryan Kesler* (HBR) 15-16 Patrice Bergeron (THR) 16-17 Alexander Ovechkin (ALP) 17-18 Sean Couturier (PHI) 18-19 Mark Stone (BSB) 19-20 Zach Parise (KNB) 20-21 Anze Kopitar (HBR) The league stopped tracking this arbitrary award after the 20-21 season. |
| Maurice Richard (Top Scorer) |  | 09-10 Jeff Carter (STO) 46 goals 10-11 Alex Ovechkin (PHI) 50 goals 11-12 Jussi Jokinen (GUN) 47 goals 12-13 Evgeni Malkin (BSB) 88 goals 13-14 John Tavares (NOK) 74 goals 14-15 Tyler Seguin (THR) 55 goals 15-16 Tyler Seguin (THR) 78 goals 16-17 Alex Ovechkin (ALP) 61 goals 17-18 Jamie Benn (GBT) 59 goals 18-19 John Tavares (PRT) 75 goals 19-20 Nikita Kucherov (KNB) 65 goals 20-21 Mika Zibanejad (HBR) 43 goals 21-22 Alex DeBrincat (KNB) 47 goals 22-23 David Pastrnak (NOK) 61 goals 23-24 Leon Draisaitl (GUN) 88 goals 24-25 Nathan MacKinnon (SHE) 85 goals 25-26 Cale Makar (PHI) 70 goals |
| Art Ross (Points Leader) |  | 09-10 Jeff Carter (STO) 100 pts 10-11 Vincent Lecavalier (GIA, nka KEN) 107 pts 11-12 Andy McDonald (BRS, nka KEN) 102 pts 12-13 Evgeni Malkin (BSB) 178 pts 13-14 Jonathan Toews (AVI) 158 pts 14-15 Tyler Seguin (THR) 113 pts 15-16 Tyler Seguin (THR) 159 pts 16-17 Alex Ovechkin (ALP) 120 pts 17-18 Jamie Benn (GBT) 126 pts 18-19 Tyler Seguin (PRT) 163 pts 19-20 Steven Stamkos (KNB) 135 pts 20-21 Mika Zibanejad (HBR) 84 pts 21-22 Patrick Kane (POU) 100 pts 22-23 David Pastrnak (NOK) 114 pts 23-24 Leon Draisaitl (GUN) 173 pts 24-25 Nathan MacKinnon (SHE) 167 pts 25-26 Cale Makar (PHI) 141 pts |
| GM of the Year (Top GM) |  | 11-12 Angus Yuen (BUL nka GBT) 12-13 Storm GM (STO) 13-14 Storm GM (STO) 14-15 Bombers GM (BOM) 15-16 Oliver DC (GBT) & Brian L (HBR) 16-17 Daniel B (PAR) and Ben C (ALP) 17-18 Hon L (GUN) 18-19 Tony W (PRT) 19-20 Brian L (HBR) 20-21 Brian L (HBR), Hon L (GUN), Tony W (PRT) and Brian L (Kenobi) for entertaining the league with multiple offer sheets. The league stopped tracking this arbitrary award after the 20-21 season. |
| NHL Draft #1 Pick | Taylor Hall Award (Team that won the lottery) | 09-10 Taylor Hall (PHI) 10-11 Ryan Nugent Hopkins (COY) 11-12 Nail Yakupov (TGT) 12-13 Nathan McKinnon (SHE) 13-14 Aaron Ekblad (COY) 14-15 Connor McDavid (TGT) 15-16 Auston Matthews (SHE) 16-17 Nolan Patrick (TGT) 17-18 Rasmus Dahlin (WOR) 18-19 Jack Hughes (CDR) 19-20 A. Lafreniere (ADV) 20-21 Owen Power (ADV) 21-22 Shane Wright (CDR) 22-23 Connor Bedard (JMX) 23-24 Macklin Cellibrini (HEL) 24-25 Matthew Schaefer (BSB) 25-26 TBD |